SEND Reforms: Our response to the DfE consultation on EOTAS (Education Otherwise Than At School)
Actions
This page shares our response to the national consultation that was held by the Department for Education to seek views on how to strengthen arrangements for children and young people receiving special educational provision through an education otherwise than at school (EOTAS) arrangement, not attending school and receiving alternative provision because of health reasons or receiving alternative provision in accredited online education providers.
Following analysis of all responses by the Department for Eduction, the outcome of this public consultation will be available via this link: SEND reform: education otherwise than at school - GOV.UK
Chapter 1: Reforming EOTAS
Should local authorities continue to decide whether a child receives EOTAS, or should responsibility sit elsewhere?
The local authority should retain responsibility for the statutory decision. EOTAS depends on a legal test, assessed needs, the EHCP, the suitability of all school, post-16 institution or other education setting options, and local sufficiency. The model should support clear stewardship and quality assurance by the local authority, rather than centralised control over every aspect of delivery.
The SEND system should operate on the principle that EOTAS is an exceptional arrangement, used only where provision cannot appropriately be delivered in any school, post-16 institution or other education setting. Reform should therefore focus not only on decision-making processes but also on improving inclusion, strengthening ordinarily available provision and increasing specialist capacity so that fewer children reach the point where EOTAS is required.
We do not support transferring decision-making wholly to the setting overseeing a Specialist Provision Package. A setting-led model could enable more children to be directed off-site without a sufficiently independent assessment of whether education in a school, post-16 institution or other education setting is genuinely inappropriate. It could also blur the distinction between section 61 EOTAS, section 19 alternative provision and school-arranged off-site provision, weaken parental confidence and create incentives to move responsibility rather than improve inclusion.
If the Government proceeds with a stronger setting role, the local authority should retain final approval and oversight. Shared responsibility should be explicit: schools, specialist settings, health partners and local authorities should work together to prevent unmet need, sustain belonging, improve inclusion and support reintegration where appropriate.
There should be mandatory child and parent involvement, clear evidence that reasonable adjustments and suitable setting-based options have been considered, independent multi-agency advice, written reasons, review points and a right to challenge. A named setting should remain accountable for the child's curriculum, safeguarding, outcomes, sense of belonging and reintegration where appropriate, but should not be able to remove a child from on-site education unilaterally.
What factors should be considered when deciding whether EOTAS is appropriate?
The central consideration when determining whether EOTAS is appropriate should be the statutory section 61 test: whether it is inappropriate for a child or young person's special educational provision to be delivered in a school, post-16 institution or other education setting. Decisions should be based on a comprehensive assessment of the child or young person's needs and circumstances, including previous support and reasonable adjustments, health and safeguarding considerations, the views of the child and family, available education provision, and longer-term outcomes such as preparation for adulthood. Where education is proposed to take place primarily at home, consideration should also be given to home circumstances, including whether a social care assessment is required.
National guidance should provide greater clarity on the professionals best placed to advise on EOTAS and the evidence required to support decision-making. A recommendation for EOTAS should not be based solely on the failure of a single placement, delays in assessment, gaps in health provision, placement shortages or wider system pressures. Instead, decisions should demonstrate that all relevant education, health and care evidence has been considered, alongside the realistic range of available provision and support.
The framework should also recognise the needs of looked-after children, ensuring decisions take account of care arrangements, placement stability, educational history, and the views of relevant professionals, including the Virtual School Head and social worker. EOTAS should not become a substitute for securing appropriate education where placement instability, exclusions or care arrangements create challenges.
Finally, while clear national guidance and robust decision-making are important, the long-term focus should be on reducing the factors that lead to EOTAS requests through earlier intervention, stronger inclusion, timely access to health and therapeutic support, and increased capacity within mainstream and specialist provision. This will help ensure more children and young people receive the right support, at the right time, in the most appropriate educational setting.
What safeguards should be in place when making EOTAS decisions?
Safeguards should include clear national criteria, robust multi-agency evidence, meaningful child and family involvement, transparent decision-making, regular review and accessible routes to challenge.
Current section 61 arrangements require the local authority to consult the child's parent or the young person. A future model should not allow EOTAS to be imposed through a setting-led decision without meaningful engagement and independent oversight.
Decisions must clearly distinguish section 19 alternative provision, section 61 EOTAS and school-arranged off-site provision. National guidance should specify who makes each decision, who remains accountable, what evidence is required, how disagreements are managed and what routes of appeal or redress are available.
No child should be moved off-site because a setting cannot or will not make reasonable adjustments, because specialist capacity is unavailable, or as an informal response to behaviour, attendance challenges or unmet need. EOTAS should not become a mechanism for compensating for wider system failures.
For looked-after children, safeguards should require consultation with the Virtual School Head and social worker, consideration of the child's wishes and feelings, and explicit arrangements where the child is educated outside their home authority.
Any future model also requires sufficient specialist capacity, clear accountability and a practical approach to regulation, parental preference and Tribunal decisions. Without these safeguards there is a risk of inconsistent practice and inappropriate diversion away from schools and other educational settings.
How should EOTAS arrangements be quality assured?
Quality assurance should be proportionate to the EOTAS arrangement and cover safeguarding, delivery of agreed provision, curriculum suitability, attendance, engagement, progress, outcomes, value for money, preparation for adulthood and the child’s continuing connection to education and community. A home tutor, online provider or mixed package should not be treated in the same way as a school or AP setting, but expectations on safer recruitment, escalation of concerns and review should be clear.
Local authorities need a clear market stewardship and oversight role, supported by provider standards, proportionate monitoring, reliable data and powers to intervene where concerns arise. This should enable authorities to identify patterns across EOTAS packages, including provider reliance, cost, quality concerns, outcomes and sufficiency gaps.
Any new duties should be funded and accompanied by investment in a suitably experienced specialist workforce to commission, monitor and review EOTAS arrangements consistently across local authorities.
Annual reviews alone are insufficient to identify emerging concerns. As a minimum, EOTAS arrangements should be reviewed termly, with more frequent reviews where provision is newly established, changing significantly, high-cost or where safeguarding concerns have been identified.
Monitoring should consider:
- Attendance and engagement
- Delivery of provision
- Academic and developmental progress
- Safeguarding
- Wellbeing
- Preparation for adulthood
- Value for money
Local authorities may require a dedicated quality assurance function where EOTAS packages are complex, high-cost or involve multiple providers.
Nationally approved or accredited provider lists could support consistency and reduce reliance on unregulated provision.
National expectations should recognise that EOTAS packages may comprise several providers. The DfE should provide clear and legally robust guidance on independent school registration requirements for tuition providers, including home-based, community-based and online provision. Arrangements should never encourage commissioners to reduce hours simply to avoid registration thresholds.
The model must not create a bureaucratic structure that smaller authorities cannot sustain. Additional oversight requirements should be proportionate, funded and integrated within existing SEND governance arrangements.
What information should be included in an individual's plan where EOTAS is used?
The plan should set out:
- The respective roles and reasonable expectations of the child or young person, family, providers and accountable lead
- The legal basis for EOTAS
- Assessed needs
- Why provision in a school, post-16 institution or other education setting is inappropriate
- Evidence considered
- The child and family's views
- Intended outcomes
- Curriculum and qualifications
- Providers and timetable
- Safeguarding arrangements
- Health and therapy input
- Funding arrangements
- Review arrangements
- Reintegration arrangements where appropriate
- Preparation for adulthood
For looked-after children, plans should align the EHCP, Personal Education Plan and Care Plan.
The plan should identify an accountable lead and clearly state:
- Who commissions, delivers and monitors each element
- Who assures the package as a whole
- What happens if provision breaks down
- Escalation processes
- How the child remains connected to an education community
The plan should describe the full educational offer rather than a fixed number of tuition hours and should allow for progression and adjustment as needs change.
How should outcomes and progress be monitored?
Monitoring should draw on evidence from providers, families, the child or young person, the linked setting and professionals. Providers should be required to report emerging concerns, reduced engagement or insufficient progress promptly so that support can be adjusted before arrangements break down.
Monitoring should consider:
- Educational progress
- Engagement
- Attendance
- Wellbeing
- Accreditation
- Preparation for adulthood
- Social inclusion
- Sense of belonging
Success should be measured by improved outcomes, stronger inclusion, improved wellbeing, greater belonging and increased confidence in the SEND system, rather than simply a reduction in EOTAS arrangements.
Where possible, reviews should align with EHCP annual reviews, Personal Education Plan reviews and care reviews.
What should happen when circumstances change and EOTAS may no longer be needed?
The arrangement should be reviewed promptly using current evidence and the child's views. Any move away from EOTAS should be planned, proportionate and based on whether needs can now be met safely and effectively within a school, post-16 institution or other education setting.
Reintegration should be actively considered where it supports belonging, curriculum breadth and long-term outcomes, but should not be treated as the only measure of success or pursued where it is not in the child's best interests.
For looked-after children, reviews should anticipate placement changes and ensure continuity of education.
How can EOTAS arrangements better support progression and preparation for adulthood?
EOTAS should be built around a clear curriculum and progression pathway rather than simply tuition hours. For older learners this should include accreditation, independence, employability, community participation, health and wellbeing, and transition planning.
Packages should be ambitious and keep future options open across education, employment, training and adult life.
How can EOTAS arrangements better support reintegration where appropriate?
Reintegration should be planned where it is realistic and beneficial but should not be treated as the sole indicator of success.
Children should remain connected to a school, post-16 institution or other education setting wherever possible. Plans should include relationship-building, phased transitions, reasonable adjustments, pastoral support and regular review.
Reintegration must be carefully planned and personalised to avoid a cliff-edge transition between EOTAS and full-time attendance.
Chapter 2: Supporting children and young people on existing EOTAS arrangements
Do you agree with the proposal to protect existing secondary-aged and post-16 EOTAS arrangements when reforms are introduced?
Yes, broadly. Existing secondary-aged and post-16 learners should be protected from sudden disruption where they have established, highly individualised packages. However, protection should not amount to exemption from proportionate review. All existing arrangements should continue to be reviewed on a person-centred and evidence-based basis, with particular attention to quality, safeguarding, progression and preparation for adulthood. Changes should only be made where they are supported by evidence, meaningful engagement and a suitable alternative, rather than solely because reforms have been introduced.
What support would be needed for children already receiving EOTAS?
Children and families will need continuity, clear communication and careful review. Support should include a named lead where needed, access to professional advice, quality assurance of current provision and reassurance that changes will be based on evidence, engagement and suitable alternatives, not on reform implementation alone.
Do you agree with reviewing primary-aged children receiving EOTAS at the end of primary phase?
Yes, in principle, because transition to secondary education is a natural review point. The review should not assume that school-based provision is automatically suitable. It should consider progress, current need, family and child views, health advice, local provision and whether transition can be achieved safely and successfully.
How should transitions into specialist provision or other arrangements be managed?
Transitions should be planned early with the child, family and receiving setting. They should build on what has worked, identify risks and specify support for the new setting. Phased steps, relationship building, reasonable adjustments and clear review points are essential. Specialist provision should be used where it will improve outcomes, belonging and progression.
What safeguards would be needed during transition and review processes?
Safeguards should include clear criteria, transparent decisions, child and family involvement, professional advice, continuity of education and routes to raise concerns. No child should lose provision before a suitable alternative is in place. Reviews should test whether provision remains necessary and ambitious without creating inappropriate pressure to reintegrate.
Transitional arrangements should provide stability for children and young people already receiving EOTAS, without removing the need for proportionate review. Existing provision should not be withdrawn abruptly, but all arrangements should remain subject to appropriate oversight of quality, progress, safeguarding and preparation for adulthood.
Chapter 3: Alternative provision for health reasons
How can responsibilities between schools and local authorities be clarified?
Guidance should clearly distinguish school duties, the local authority's section 19 duty, section 61 EOTAS and school arranged off-site provision. Schools should lead early support, reasonable adjustments, family contact, curriculum continuity and reintegration. Local authorities should arrange suitable education where the section 19 threshold is met and work with schools and health partners so children do not wait while accountability is disputed.
Clarity and guidance should be provided on what the ICB’s role is in determining when EOTAS is required for health reasons. The DfE should clarify responsibility where a child is new to the area, has been excluded or removed from specialist provision, is awaiting assessment or placement, or requires a single tuition provider for a substantial weekly programme. The guidance must address provider registration and compliance directly, without creating a perverse incentive to reduce the educational offer for children with SEND.
What should schools be expected to do before alternative provision for health needs is arranged?
Schools should make early, reasonable and evidenced efforts to support attendance and learning. This should include pastoral support, reasonable adjustments, use of health advice, continued family contact, access to work where appropriate, short-term remote access where suitable and reintegration planning. They should provide clear evidence of what has been tried and what further support is needed.
Advice from ICBs and health services should sought and the DfE should provide robust guidance on who is accountable and how concerns are escalated when missing healthcare prevents a child from attending school.
Delays can be reduced through clear referral routes, timely school and health evidence, agreed thresholds, practical local protocols and commissioned provision that can be mobilised quickly. The aim should be a consistent, accessible pathway so education is not delayed while agencies resolve accountability.
The DfE should issue clear guidance to ICB’s on their responsibility for commissioning necessary healthcare required whilst a child is unable to attend school for health reasons and how timely assessment and provision will be secured for these children. It should also be outlined how at a system level, delays within in NHS assessments or provision are identified, monitored and reported.
This could be via the school nursing service which is embedded within education settings. Clinical care would be arranged via the NHS and delivered by NHS staff. This can include healthcare assistants who work under qualified nurses.
How can continuity of education be improved during periods of illness?
Continuity is best supported by keeping the child connected to their school wherever possible, maintaining access to curriculum learning and using flexible or blended approaches where suitable. Alternative provision should maintain progression, relationships and confidence, rather than simply fill a gap.
How should reintegration be supported when a child can return to school?
Reintegration should be planned jointly with phased return, reasonable adjustments, pastoral support, curriculum catch up where needed and clear review points. The focus should be safe and sustainable return, not attendance alone. Plans should allow flexibility where health needs fluctuate.
What barriers currently prevent effective support for children with health needs?
Barriers include unclear thresholds, delays in health advice, limited provision, weak information sharing and insufficient joint planning. Children with anxiety, neurodevelopmental or complex health needs can fall between systems if guidance is unclear. There is also a risk that elective home education becomes a route into EOTAS or bespoke home tuition requests. This reinforces the need for earlier support, clear thresholds and a stronger graduated response. Reform should also improve schools’ timely access to specialist advice, information and workforce development so staff feel equipped to support children with health needs and manage safe, sustainable reintegration.
Chapter 4: Accredited online education providers
How should accredited online education be used within alternative provision?
Accredited online education should be one part of a planned package, not a default or long-term substitute for face-to-face education unless clearly justified by need. It can support continuity, curriculum access and progression, but should be regularly reviewed, linked to outcomes and connected to a school or lead education setting wherever possible.
What benefits do online providers offer?
Online providers can offer flexibility, continuity during illness or transition, access to subjects or qualifications, and a less overwhelming learning environment for some children and young people. Used well, online education can help sustain engagement while wider support is arranged or as a bridge back towards face-to-face provision.
What risks need to be managed?
Risks include isolation, reduced safeguarding visibility, weak attendance monitoring, limited social interaction, narrow curriculum and provision continuing because it is available rather than because it is right. Online education must not mask unmet need or reduce urgency to secure appropriate school, FE or specialist provision.
Whilst accredited online education can provide flexibility, continuity and access to learning, there is a risk that it becomes a substitute for securing appropriate specialist provision, rebuilding inclusion within schools or addressing local sufficiency challenges. Online provision is of variable quantity with no set standards or compulsory accreditation/registration. There are also risks around actual engagement - attendance online is not the same as meaningful participation. A child may log in but have limited engagement, making progress and outcomes harder to assess
Reduced preparation for adulthood opportunities. These can be harder to achieve through predominantly online packages.
Online provision should not be used as a long term solution simply because it is available. Any use of online education should be underpinned by clear accountability, safeguarding oversight, meaningful monitoring of engagement and progress and consideration of the child or young person's social development, wellbeing, sense of belonging and preparation for adulthood.
What quality assurance and safeguarding measures should apply?
Online providers should be accredited and subject to national standards covering safeguarding, attendance, identity and engagement checks, curriculum quality, staff suitability, progress monitoring, information sharing and complaints. The responsible school, FE setting or local authority must know whether the child is attending, engaging and progressing, with clear escalation if concerns arise. The current voluntary nature of online accreditation leaves a gap where online education is a child's main or only source of education. The Government should clarify whether accreditation will become mandatory in defined circumstances, how quality will be monitored between inspections and what commissioners should do where the market cannot provide an accredited option. Online provision should not become a default route for moving children away from school or a substitute for securing appropriate specialist capacity.
How can online provision support positive outcomes and progression?
Online provision can support outcomes where it is linked to a clear plan, curriculum progression, accreditation where relevant and wider preparation for next steps. Its impact should be judged by engagement, wellbeing, progress, belonging and future options, not simply delivery of sessions.